Guest Post: Why I’m Not Interested in a Mexican Katniss

By Guinevere Zoyana Thomas

Earlier this year, Matt de la Peña asked the publishing industry one of the most thought-provoking questions ever: “Where is the African American Harry Potter or the Mexican Katniss?

His question was part of a conversation about why there aren’t that many POC equivalents to such iconic characters in YA and MG.

There doesn’t seem to be a good enough excuse for there not to be more Latino characters in kid lit especially with the Latino population rapidly growing, so to say there isn’t a market for it is just undetermined fabrication. I, for one, identify as an Afro-Cubana who would gladly buy a book from a Latina author that featured a Latina protagonist in a heartbeat!

But the truth is, I’m not sure I want a Mexican Katniss or a black Harry Potter or even an Asian Percy Jackson. A small part of me feels that if I say I do, I’d be telling the world that in order for a POC character to be great, we’d  have to follow thedefault” archetype. Everybody knows it: white, skinny, Christian, hetero, and because girls are so popular in YA, born female.

Comparisons are wonderful, because, I mean, who doesn’t want to be compared to what’s considered a great character, but I think it’s more than fair to say that boys and girls of color have earned the chance to be the models of their own standards, and, unfortunately, the only ones who don’t think about how representation in kid lit is important are the ones who are swimming in characters dedicated to their own images.

23117815One YA book that stood out to me this year was Dia of the Dead by Brit Brinson. It had zombies, it had action, and it definitely had drama. But most importantly to me, it had something that’s always left out of the conversation about Latinos in fiction–an Afro-Latina protagonist named Dia.

Her character was so amazingly memorable and struggled with the many things most Afro-Latinas go through in terms of identity that it was too hard to draw a comparison to another character in a similar situation who just happens to be a non-white Latina. All I could really give her credit for was being Dia, and isn’t that what we’re all really looking for in a character?

I don’t think we need a Mexican Katniss, but instead a chance to be on a bookshelf next to Katniss in our own stories with our own myths and legends. And it wouldn’t hurt if she had an amazing name like Citlalli, or even Amaryllis.

What I hope for her is to be a character that is a hero all on her own, clearing her own path and setting her own standard.

About the Blogger/Aspiring writer:

GuinevereGuinevere Zoyana Thomas is one half of the ever so silent and deadly “Twinjas” @Twinja Book Reviews. When she isn’t perfecting back handsprings or working on her red belt in Tang Soo Do, she’s going H.A.M. editing her diverse time-travel YA novel under the pseudonym “GL Tomas.”

Facebook for Twinja Book Reviews 

Facebook for GL Thomas

Tumblr for Twinja Book Reviews


Author Blog 

Book Blog

4 comments on “Guest Post: Why I’m Not Interested in a Mexican Katniss

  1. A goal for everyone: “to be a character that is a hero all on her own, clearing her own path and setting her own standard”. Thanks for sharing about DIA of the Dead, sounds like something my students (middle school) and I would like.

  2. The answer to Matt de la Pena’s question is simple: (1) the authors who wrote The Hunger Games and Harry Potter are superb authors, and (2) with all the talk about the need for more Diverse Books it doesn’t apply in the real world of agents/editors/publishers.
    I respectfully submit that we do need a Mexican Katniss to make Mexican Heroines very popular with American teenagers. The best way to reach this goal is by publishers asking well know authors (like those who wrote the two mega-best sellers mentioned above) and ask them to write YA fiction with a Mexican boy of girl as the MC. These famous and skilled authors will deliver a Mexican Katniss.And also ask those in the publishing industry to put extra effort and time when a book like a Mexican Katniss reaches their desk, not just wait for it to arrive. Without help from the publishing industry and without famous authors writing Latino YA fiction, a Mexican Katniss will not be on shelves of book stores. Just my views.

    • You make an interesting point. It’s definitely not wrong, but we need MORE than just non-latino white authors telling our stories. We need to be telling them too with the freedom to do so.

      To quote author Ellen Oh:

      “It isn’t enough that white authors write diversity – although it is important because it reflects our world. But I think it is more important for diverse authors to show our kids that they really can be anything they want to be.”

      Sadly, we end up with cultural appropriation, or worse, getting told non-latino white authors tell our stories better than we do.

      Just my two cents =)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s